Skip to main content

WHY BUREAUCRACY FAILED-2. MORE AUTHORITY TO TOP

More and more authority to one chair leads to more and more concentration of decision making power leaving subordinates more and more powerless. In our bureaucracy we see as time is passing top bureaucrats are concentrating more authority . Indian model of bureaucracy  gives little room to its subordinates to innovate. They are expected to follow the dictate. If the government claims to be provider of services to public , they need to focus on service delivery system. The delivery system improves when delivery agents are motivated to deliver. This motivation comes when the delivery agents feel prized for their services. Contrary to this accepted fact, in bureaucracy top bureaucratic echelon relies on dictates , fear and punishment  in place of motivation, encouragement and rewards. Lower ranked officers and field level employees feel that if they don't follow the dictate they will be punished. They also know if they achieve something splendid they will not be rewarded. Rather there is every possibility that after accomplishing the task in a wonderful way they may get transferred to some very unsuitable place only because their top boss may be convinced against them. Top bureaucracy is particularly immune to any complain coming from the lower rung. In fact the top is so powerful that if anybody in the system dares to suggest something contrary to top's opinions he is sidelined and may be forced to go to some remote positions. Authority makes the bosses averse to suggestions and criticism. They start living in their own den. If you attend a government meeting of top bureaucrats you will find only tat top boss is speaking and all others are mere listeners. If any one tries to raise a point, tries to suggest any idea he is scolded for his ideas . Most probably he is not allowed to complete the sentence. And if anyone tries to raise some doubts or to tell some problems in implementation or to share some of his personal issues he is termed as NAKARAS(useless). Recently we see a very derogatory trend of using abusive language by top bosses for their subordinates because they know they can't be held responsible for their actions . Their authority provides them shield . They feel fearless in misbehaving with their subordinates whereas subordinates feel fear even in complying with the dictates. This alienates those who actually deliver the services. Authority makes bosses arrogant and diminishes the quality of services. And ultimately the end user, the general public who is the ultimate beneficiary of a service suffers. Higher is  the authority of bureaucracy lower is the quality of services given to the public .
      The above is about the execution part. And now see policy making part. Further as concentration of power in top bureaucracy increases too bureaucracy shifts away from ground reality. It loses its contact with grass root. Those who can provide ground reality, those who can provide feed back are demoralized lot. They do not get prestige from their bosses. There is no official channel to provide suggestions and feedbacks. So the lower level officers and field level staff feel no belongingness with their job. They do their job only because they get salary and they feel frightened that if they don't do their job they may be suspended or even terminated. But in this process they even provide wrong data to inflate their achievement. As they can't give their suggestion they don't take extra effort, they don't innovate for better results. Rather they follow words of the instruction and even give misleading data to justify government's policy. Besides this there are other bottlenecks as well. In india there is a little research and surve work for evaluation. And no other person can provide more accurate account than ground level officers and workers but they are deliberately kept away from top to create a sense of awe among them. In this way authority alienates lower lever officers and staffs who could provide ideas  suitable for better policy making. Ultimately general public is the sufferer . Higher is  the authority of bureaucracy lower is the quality of services given to the public .

Popular posts from this blog

SHRIMADBHAGAVAD GEETA CHAPTER 2 SHLOKA 47

गीता अध्याय 2 श्लोक 47 ----------------------------------- कर्मण्येवाधिकारस्ते मा फलेषु कदाचन।  मा कर्मफलहेतुर्भुर्मा ते संगोऽस्त्वकर्मणि॥ तेरा कर्म करने में ही अधिकार है, उसके फलों में कभी नहीं। इसलिए तू कर्मों के फल हेतु मत हो तथा तेरी कर्म न करने में भी आसक्ति न हो  ॥47॥ कर्मपथ की सावधानियों और विशेषताओं को बताते हुए श्रीकृष्ण इस पथ के सम्बंध में समझाये हैं कि अन्तिम लक्ष्य तो साँख्य बुद्धि को प्राप्त करना है लेकिन उस तक पहुंचने का मार्ग योग है, कर्मपथ है। इस पथ को ध्यान पूर्वक समझना और उसका अभ्यास करना बहुत जरूरी है तभी हम साँख्य और उसके पश्चात परमब्रह्म को प्राप्त कर सकते हैं। इसके अतिरिक्त कोई और रास्ता नहीं है जो हमारेके कल्याण का मार्ग प्रशस्त कर सके।        श्रीकृष्ण समझते हुए कहते हैं कि कर्म ही वो मार्ग है जिसपर हम चलकर के परम नैष्कर्म्य की स्थिति तक पहुँच सकते हैं लेकिन जब हम कर्म करते हैं तो उस कर्म की विशेषता और सावधानियों को समझना अनिवार्य है अन्यथा हम कर्मपथ से भटक जाते हैं।       ये विशेषताएँ और सावधानियाँ निम्नवत हैं----- 1....
 Politics is not all about confrontation. It's not a game to demean opponanents. History of politics tells us it was developed by society to find a common place for different warning factions of population. In this course idea of  state, sovereign power, government  etc emerged and orderly society was expected. So politics has as many branches as one can think, but interestingly those involved in politics dont understand the significance of it all the time. The very crux of the politics from the very inception of this concept is negotiation. If u avoid meaningful negotiation based on the innovation u r not doing politics, rather u r bullying society's moral . If u are government u r destined to win ur people by ur ideas and not by ur number. Such a task is not politics, its just militarization. The same erroneous decision was taken by the Kauravas, by the Nazis, by the Europeans in 18th-19th cent and by our own present govt. The only difference is that our present govt is...

13.आत्मविजय अभियान-पाठ 13-हम दुखी क्यों हो जाते हैं?

13.आत्मविजय अभियान-पाठ 13-हम दुखी क्यों हो जाते हैं? हम जीवन में बहुत सारी घट चुकी घटनाओं, घट रही घटनाओं और घटित होने वाली घटनाओं की आशंका से खुश और दुख अनुभव कर कर के तनाव लेते रहते हैं। संसार की समस्त घटनाओं को कई अलग अलग तरह से समझा जा सकता है। अपने जीवन में घट रही विभिन्न घटनाओं को समझने का एक तरीका ये होता है कि हम उनको दो वृहत श्रेणियों में बाँट देते हैं, सृजन और विनाश और जिनपर विलाप करते हैं उनको विनाश की श्रेणी में  रखते हैं और जिनपर प्रसन्नता अनुभव करते हैं उनको सृजन  की श्रेणी में रखते हैं।           इस तथ्य को समझने के लिए हम महाभारत  के युद्ध का प्रसंग ले सकते हैं। युद्ध के मैदान में जब कौरव और पांडव पक्षों की सेनाएं आमने सामने आती हैं तो अर्जुन जो अबतक अपने जीवन सभी युद्धों में विजयी रहा है अचानक युद्ध का विरोधी हो जाता है जिसपर श्रीकृष्ण उसे झिड़की भी देते हैं। अब सवाल उठता है कि श्रीकृष्ण ऐसा क्यों कह रहें हैं। अर्जुन तो युद्ध का, मार काट का विरोध ही न कर रहा है, वह तो युद्ध के पश्चात समाज में फैलने वाली परिस्थिति  की ही न ...