Skip to main content

WHY BUREAUCRACY FAILED--1.LACK.OF TRAINING

The largest but one of the most formalized organizations in India is Indian bureaucracy. It's claimed to be key to India's development. If this claim is taken as truth then reason for India's failure on most of the fronts will naturally be attributed to it. Text books deal in length the reasons behind failure of India's bureaucracy. Many scholars have also explained the reasons in detail. But what's an account of failures of bureaucracy by a bureaucrat himself? Of course from experience a long list can be produced, but here we will be confined to only one, rest will be discussed at some latter appropriate time.
          India's permanent bureaucracy is expected to deliver anything. A framework of hierarchy has been established which is expected to do anything entrusted to it , whether it's meant for that or not. Size and area of functioning of the government is so big that it covers almost everything beneath the sky. And government has only one agency to perform every task falling under the ambit . Whenever a new policy is prepared the bureaucracy is entrusted with the task and expected to deliver. Interestingly from top to bottom no one in the system has experience to do the new task , no one has any idea to do what. What's the practice is that a letter or a policy paper is circulated from the top to bottom detailing what to do and the rank and file is expected to read the letter or paper and to act accordingly. No training, no orientation of any worth is given. A person dealing with water resources may be suddenly transferred to a welfare department, for instance and he is expected to do wonders . Interestingly a bureaucrat  who may be a trained engineer may be asked to solve intrinsics of finance, a bureaucrat, who is a trained historian may be asked to go to health department to take responsibility of improving health services. Interestingly the most of the force below consists of highly untrained people. Almost every government policy which is to reach to the grass root level is to be executed by block and panchayat level employees who have least idea to implement the policy. Without any training, without any orientation they are forced to perform and those responsible for their monitoring are equally untrained for the job at hand. At the same time there is a flow of dictate from higher to lower level and at no level there is any sense of belongingness. The entire bureaucracy which is not trained to perform a particular thing is forced to do that thing and the bureaucracy which consists of top secretary to panchayat secretary moves to do the job not at the instance of any dedication , rather it's done only as a part of government service for salary. There is no attachment with the task allotted.
    And interestingly this largely untrained and detached force is expected to deliver goods. One of the best examples is the SWAKSHATA ABHIYAN, popularly called ODF Abhiyan. The aim was to provide sanitation services in both rural and urban areas. In Bihar in rural areas panchayat sachivas, and BDOs were entrusted to the task . For their help a Block Level Coordinator was appointed on contract. Now see, neither Panchayat Sachiv, nor BDO, nor even district level DRDA's officers were given a formal training with the condition of evaluation. District Magistrates were asked to ensure the achievement, who in turn implemented the scheme as per their own understanding. No one who was involved was trained to develop a sense of belongingness with the scheme. A large force of officers and field staffs were engaged without any formal training of basics. Coercion was the only force to mobilize the machinery. And this is equally true for almost every government program. The result is obvious. All in the system do a task not due to motivation, rather due to fear of coercion which is driving force to achieve the goal. This method is neither modern nor democratic . This only strengthens master servant  pattern of working where one person gives orders,  others follow not due to dedication but due to fear of punishment. And so the system has to fail in delivering the result and it actually fails.

Popular posts from this blog

SHRIMADBHAGAVAD GEETA CHAPTER 2 SHLOKA 47

गीता अध्याय 2 श्लोक 47 ----------------------------------- कर्मण्येवाधिकारस्ते मा फलेषु कदाचन।  मा कर्मफलहेतुर्भुर्मा ते संगोऽस्त्वकर्मणि॥ तेरा कर्म करने में ही अधिकार है, उसके फलों में कभी नहीं। इसलिए तू कर्मों के फल हेतु मत हो तथा तेरी कर्म न करने में भी आसक्ति न हो  ॥47॥ कर्मपथ की सावधानियों और विशेषताओं को बताते हुए श्रीकृष्ण इस पथ के सम्बंध में समझाये हैं कि अन्तिम लक्ष्य तो साँख्य बुद्धि को प्राप्त करना है लेकिन उस तक पहुंचने का मार्ग योग है, कर्मपथ है। इस पथ को ध्यान पूर्वक समझना और उसका अभ्यास करना बहुत जरूरी है तभी हम साँख्य और उसके पश्चात परमब्रह्म को प्राप्त कर सकते हैं। इसके अतिरिक्त कोई और रास्ता नहीं है जो हमारेके कल्याण का मार्ग प्रशस्त कर सके।        श्रीकृष्ण समझते हुए कहते हैं कि कर्म ही वो मार्ग है जिसपर हम चलकर के परम नैष्कर्म्य की स्थिति तक पहुँच सकते हैं लेकिन जब हम कर्म करते हैं तो उस कर्म की विशेषता और सावधानियों को समझना अनिवार्य है अन्यथा हम कर्मपथ से भटक जाते हैं।       ये विशेषताएँ और सावधानियाँ निम्नवत हैं----- 1....
 Politics is not all about confrontation. It's not a game to demean opponanents. History of politics tells us it was developed by society to find a common place for different warning factions of population. In this course idea of  state, sovereign power, government  etc emerged and orderly society was expected. So politics has as many branches as one can think, but interestingly those involved in politics dont understand the significance of it all the time. The very crux of the politics from the very inception of this concept is negotiation. If u avoid meaningful negotiation based on the innovation u r not doing politics, rather u r bullying society's moral . If u are government u r destined to win ur people by ur ideas and not by ur number. Such a task is not politics, its just militarization. The same erroneous decision was taken by the Kauravas, by the Nazis, by the Europeans in 18th-19th cent and by our own present govt. The only difference is that our present govt is...

13.आत्मविजय अभियान-पाठ 13-हम दुखी क्यों हो जाते हैं?

13.आत्मविजय अभियान-पाठ 13-हम दुखी क्यों हो जाते हैं? हम जीवन में बहुत सारी घट चुकी घटनाओं, घट रही घटनाओं और घटित होने वाली घटनाओं की आशंका से खुश और दुख अनुभव कर कर के तनाव लेते रहते हैं। संसार की समस्त घटनाओं को कई अलग अलग तरह से समझा जा सकता है। अपने जीवन में घट रही विभिन्न घटनाओं को समझने का एक तरीका ये होता है कि हम उनको दो वृहत श्रेणियों में बाँट देते हैं, सृजन और विनाश और जिनपर विलाप करते हैं उनको विनाश की श्रेणी में  रखते हैं और जिनपर प्रसन्नता अनुभव करते हैं उनको सृजन  की श्रेणी में रखते हैं।           इस तथ्य को समझने के लिए हम महाभारत  के युद्ध का प्रसंग ले सकते हैं। युद्ध के मैदान में जब कौरव और पांडव पक्षों की सेनाएं आमने सामने आती हैं तो अर्जुन जो अबतक अपने जीवन सभी युद्धों में विजयी रहा है अचानक युद्ध का विरोधी हो जाता है जिसपर श्रीकृष्ण उसे झिड़की भी देते हैं। अब सवाल उठता है कि श्रीकृष्ण ऐसा क्यों कह रहें हैं। अर्जुन तो युद्ध का, मार काट का विरोध ही न कर रहा है, वह तो युद्ध के पश्चात समाज में फैलने वाली परिस्थिति  की ही न ...